Wednesday, December 19, 2012

The Right’s ‘Limited Government’ Scam

A good read by Robert Parry.

A favorite line from the American Right – both well-educated libertarians and know-nothing Tea Partiers – is that the Founders believed in “limited government” and the United States must return to that constitutional principle. But the argument is both nonsensical and insulting.

Everyone believes in “limited government” – unless you’re a totalitarian or a fan of absolute monarchies. Liberals, conservatives, socialists, free-market ideologues and pretty much everyone in between believe in limitations of government power. The point of having a constitution is to set the limits and rules for a government.
...

Today’s Right doesn’t want to acknowledge this history because it destroys the right-wing narrative by revealing the Framers to be advocates of a strong central government and opponents of states’ rights.
...

Indeed, this current right-wing attack on “federal overreach” has been around since the 1950s and the civil rights movement, which put an end to Jim Crow laws in the South. The Right’s claim is essentially neo-Confederate and harkens back to the South’s efforts prior to the Civil War to insist that slave-states had the right to nullify federal laws and ultimately to secede from the Union.
...

As part of that propaganda effort, wealthy right-wingers, like the Koch Brothers, invested heavily in think tanks and academic institutions where “scholars” cherry-picked quotes from key Framers, particularly Madison, to distort the history surrounding the Constitution. This false history was then packaged and sold to ill-informed Tea Party types who fancied themselves as channeling the anti-government passions of the Founders.

For instance, one right-wing canard about the Second Amendment is that the Framers wanted an armed citizenry so the people could go to war with the government to protect individual liberties. The reality, of course, was entirely different. Aristocrats like Madison and Washington wanted armed militias so the government could maintain order in the face of disruptions like Shays’ Rebellion as well as to resist Native Americans on the frontiers and to put down slave revolts.
The real reason for 'limited government', of course, is to let the 1% roll over the rest of us unimpeded. The money boys mask their desire with all that other shit so the 'tards will buy into it.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

for more on this I highly recommend "Tempest at Dawn" by James Best. It's all this and more. Enjoy and thanks for your hard work. I am usually a lurker, but I had to post this time.

BadTux said...

The "limited government" scam actually dates even further back than the 1950's. The Confederates evoked it for why they were seceding -- the government had no right to restrict what states slaves could be carried to, and Abraham Lincoln was going to steal all their slaves. The Emancipation Proclamation pretty much emphasized that to them, though the near-destruction of Lee's army at Gettysburg (he lost half his manpower there either to death, injury, or desertion) pretty much ended any chance of the South getting revenge on Lincoln for his "imperial overreach".

In other words: "limited government" today is just code words for "right to keep slaves or near-slaves". The right to ban abortions (i.e. making women slaves to men), the right to lynch uppity nigras (Florida's "stand your ground" law), etc. Same old, same old.

- Badtux the Slavery-hatin' Penguin

Gordon said...

Thank you both.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

[p]Nehemiah wouldn't be so emotionally [url=http://www.maxwomenbillig.com]air max women billig[/url] devastated by hearing that Jerusalem was in a similar condition it has been over the past 150 years . In the end of the year, she obtained the 1988 Sullivan Award . Due to the peculiarity of the appearance of the boots, most people do not [url=http://www.maxwomenbillig.com]air max 90 women[/url] wish to wear them before . A lovely Black/Sunstone-Orion Blue edition and Black/Team Orange edition might be dropped before Halloween . This ruler has become the handiest add-ons I've used . Nope, those sneakers which get you by when you exercise or while jogging just won't do with this dance aerobic workout . This phenomenon Jordans Retro isn't discovered exclusively within the parent/child connection . What Separated Jordans From the Rest

The controversy grows and definately will carry on and evolve as new NBA players define themselves and fans become absorbed by them.[/p][p]Why Everyday Teenagers Want Wholesale Nike Shoes at Inexpensive price points

The 1st brand of Nike shoes was published that year [url=http://www.maxwomenbillig.com]nike air max women[/url] 1964 . After winning silver and gold coins within the speed skating at Calgary, [url=http://www.maxwomenbillig.com]air max women sale[/url] she won silver within the 1,000m sprint cycling . The prices along with the selection that impressive site [url=http://www.maxwomenbillig.com]air max women[/url] seems to have are basically unparalleled already in the market place . You might adore these Uggs when you consider the direction they leapt on the fashion pages and in to the mainstream . nt ruins and spectacular look at the metropolis is among the most most stunning archaeological site on earth . y well suited for trip or business vacation etc . A particular of the very significant things do mentioned before in my belief, is making guaranteed your mattress is neat and clear at all occasions . One good plan will be to find online pictures comparing fakes and authentic ones.[/p]